Balance: 1
All military in one year (see people's comments). Adding other rating requirements could really improve the map.
Creativity: 2
As above
Map Design: 4
Good map for intended single all out war in tight quarters.
Story/Instructions: 3
Could have given more information about the map.
Additional Comments:
Although I am not rating this map highly, I quite enjoyed it really. A real pluss for me was that it only took about 3 hours to play. I ran once through at 100% speed and of course got annihilated. The second attempt built up all the defenses in the first 2 years and then ran the game at 100% until near year of 8 attacks. Was quite fun. I had to reload the last year twice and run my armies around in order to win. Was a challenge and I certainly could improve upon that attempt. I used 3 barracks and found it very tight. I think I had 10 or so towers and essentially no armies left at the end. I used 3 legionaires and 3 javelin -- a lion defense would have ruined the challenge so it was not used.